The Artima Developer Community
Sponsored Link

Josh Bloch on Design
A Conversation with Effective Java Author, Josh Bloch
by Bill Venners
First Published in JavaWorld, January 4, 2002

<<  Page 15 of 19  >>


List versus Array

Bill Venners: When should I use a List versus an array as a return type or parameter type.

Josh Bloch: Darn good question. The equation changes, of course, when we get generics. Right now, if you want to provide a statically typed return value or input parameter, then you have to use an array. Lists are not statically typed, because they are ordinary old interfaces and there is no way to parameterize a user type these days. Arrays, because they are part of the language, have the distinction of being the only generic type, or parameterized type, in the language. So, if it's very important to you to have static typing, then you must use arrays.

The other thing is that arrays, once again, are fairly traditional. They are less disconcerting to people than Lists because Lists have not been widely adopted yet as the currency for passing stuff in and out.

On the other hand, Lists are nice. They are very flexible. You can pass anything, including an array, on input if you have an input parameter that's a List. So, if you are writing something where you really don't know where the input is coming from, then List makes a nice input type. If someone happens to have an array, they can say Arrays.asList and pass the array in as a List. And that doesn't involve a copy. It's a simple wrapping operation with a small, constant cost.

On the other hand, if it will be used in a more tightly defined context and you really would like to have that compile time type safety, so that you don't get a ClassCastException at run time if you were expecting a List of mail messages and you got a List of mail folders, then I think you should use the arrays. Arrays are also likely to be a bit cheaper, but on the other hand, you know how I feel about performance. If it's not a bottleneck, then you might as well do the right thing, rather than the fast thing.

So right now, a lot of people use arrays to get compile time type safety, and they certainly have my blessing until the language has generics. Once you can pass in List of mail messages and List of mail folder as two distinct types, then I think it becomes much more reasonable to take the List on input.

In fact, we haven't really thought hard about this stuff, but I suppose it would even be possible to have arrays implement the List interface. So that when you take a List on input, you can also pass an array without even wrapping it. That would be a major change. When we put the collections framework into the platform, we did it without any changes to the language. But I think it might not have been unreasonable to do exactly that, to turn arrays into Lists.

You touched on the only two reasonable input types, List and array. Don't use Vector on input, don't use HashTable. They don't cut it. Of course, Map is okay as well. On output, of course, you can use the other things if you are willing to commit to those types.

<<  Page 15 of 19  >>

Sponsored Links

Copyright © 1996-2018 Artima, Inc. All Rights Reserved. - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use