The Artima Developer Community
Sponsored Link

Survival of the Fittest Jini Services, Part I
Ensure the Quality of Web Services in the Age of Calm Computing
by Frank Sommers
First Published in JavaWorld, April 2001

<<  Page 5 of 9  >>


Guaranteed 'Quality of Service'

Jini's infrastructure is designed to actually encourage eliminating unreliable services. First, a service participates in the Jini federation based on a lease. The service's implementation must renew the lease periodically, or it will expire and no longer be advertised in lookup services. Even if a lease is kept current, a client might experience network or other communication problems with the service's implementation. A Jini client could eliminate such a service's proxy from its lookup cache. Further, it could record service implementations that often produce errors, and upon subsequent lookup, exclude them from future lookup requests.

On today's Web of HTML pages, dependability is, at best, an anecdotal property: People talk about Websites being more or less reliable, more or less fast in responding to requests, and more or less accurate in terms of the information they provide. We need to pin down dependability far better if we plan to truly depend on these ubiquitously available information systems.

Computer scientist Gerhard Weikum has studied the notions of dependability of Web-based information systems. He argues that a service-oriented Web will only start to evolve when services strive toward a guaranteed quality of service (QoS). (See Resources for a link to Weikum's online papers.) Such guarantees have both qualitative and quantitative dimensions.

Qualitative QoS means that the service produces results that are acceptable in some human context. For instance, using a flight reservation system should mean that an airline seat is reserved, a credit card is charged, and a confirmation is received. Just one or two of these actions (for instance, charging a credit card without reserving the seat) would not be acceptable from a business perspective.

Quantitative QoS implies that a service provides acceptable performance in some measurable dimension. For instance, a service that provides streaming video must provide a certain number of frames per second to achieve smoothness of the movie. Or, a reservation system must respond within a certain time period to a reservation request (a few hundred milliseconds).

A software service can verify quantitative QoS guarantees relatively easily: If our reservation system does not respond within the specified time frame, a client service can conclude that it is not meeting its QoS guarantees. Other issues pending, the client could then look for another service that performs better.

The Rio project has already proposed a QoS notion for Jini services. QoS in Rio is based on Jini services having a set of requirements to properly execute in a runtime environment (such as bandwidth, memory, or disk requirements), and a runtime environment having a well-defined set of capabilities (such as available memory, disk space, bandwidth, and so forth). Rio strives to provide the best possible execution guarantees to a Jini service by matching a service's requirements with an environment's capabilities.

The notion of specifying a software service's requirements can be extended with a stochastic scale of (quantitative) service quality under a given environment's capabilities. For instance, a streaming video service could specify that it can deliver X number of frames per second, given a network bandwidth of N. A client could obtain this information from a service's service item, which could provide Entry objects for this purpose. These numbers would still only be approximate, but it would help clients locate services that match a required QoS level.

Many service qualities are not so easy to measure. Quality, at any rate, is often in the eyes of the beholder. It is helpful at this point to establish some terminology, some of which Weikum also describes as important for Web-based information services.

<<  Page 5 of 9  >>

Sponsored Links

Copyright © 1996-2018 Artima, Inc. All Rights Reserved. - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use