The Artima Developer Community
Sponsored Link

Weblogs Forum
Kindle From Another Planet

8 replies on 1 page. Most recent reply: Apr 5, 2013 7:12 AM by Charles Howard

Welcome Guest
  Sign In

Go back to the topic listing  Back to Topic List Click to reply to this topic  Reply to this Topic Click to search messages in this forum  Search Forum Click for a threaded view of the topic  Threaded View   
Previous Topic   Next Topic
Flat View: This topic has 8 replies on 1 page
Bruce Eckel

Posts: 875
Nickname: beckel
Registered: Jun, 2003

Kindle From Another Planet (View in Weblogs)
Posted: Mar 26, 2011 4:27 PM
Reply to this message Reply
Despite being part of the microcomputer revolution from the beginning, the Kindle is the first piece of technology I've seen that feels alien to me. And I mean that in a good way.

It might be that it is so small, light and thin. It might be the e-ink screen that only uses power when it's changing pages. But I suspect that it's a combination of the design elements, and ultimately the insanely long battery life of approximately a month between recharges. The battery life of every other portable computing device has always been a factor in the back of my mind, so I have to plug in so that I don't think about it. With the Kindle, the battery life is so long that it's a non-issue, which means that the device seems to be powered by magic -- or alien technology.

I bought the Kindle as a test platform for digital book projects. Even though you're supposed to be able to create a universal format that works on all reader devices, I've learned that you never really know unless you test it on the target platforms.

I got the basic $139 version that connects to a wireless network (or you can use a USB cable directly to your computer). So far I haven't felt the need for either the 3G or the larger-format DX.

There is a lot to like about the Kindle. The e-ink screen works with the sun, rather than fighting it like your laptop must, so reading outdoors is quite workable. You can easily change the text size. You can carry lots of books on the device and it remembers the current page of each. There is a way to highlight passages (The first book I read already had some passages that were pre-highlighted, and I don't know how that happened). It has a text-to-voice reader, presumably for the blind (the text-size change is great for the visually impaired, although such persons might want to consider the larger-form DX).

There's an experimental feature that allows you to open a web browser. This is a bit awkward because of the keyboard and the mousing process, but it's workable. However, I found no way to bookmark a web page, which is rather important.

One of the greatest things about the kindle is the form factor. The size is such that you can fit your whole library into a good-sized jacket pocket, which is great, but I think my favorite aspect is that you don't have to hold a book open, or compensate for the curve of the gutter while you're reading. Everything is flat, and hands-free effortless reading is truly possible. The places where this has most plagued me is while eating and reading in bed, both of which are superior experiences on the Kindle.

I've only read one book on the Kindle so far -- a science-fiction book, so it was nothing but plain text -- but my experience with it was great. I want to read more books on the Kindle.

And there's the problem. In the past, every time I've noticed Kindle editions of books, they were always noticeably cheaper than the print versions. But apparently there was an attitude change among publishers right about now that they ought to be able to charge as much or more for the Kindle edition (probably all e-book editions) as the paper edition. I've had enough experience with publishers to know what happened: some MBA got the bright idea that they can raise ebook prices to what is paid for the print book, and get away with it (naturally, the author is usually getting the same royalty for the ebook as for the print version, so it's a big financial win for the publisher to screw both the authors and the readers). Here are a couple of examples. First, not a special case, but a book I happened to be interested in -- The Rational Optimist: Paperback, $8.84; Kindle, $12.99. Second, Seth Godin's Linchpin, just about to come out in paperback at $10.47, but available on Kindle at $18.99! So now, instead of being rewarded for shelling out the extra money for the device, I'm being punished.

My problem is that I don't like feeling cheated, and that's how this feels. I can try to look at the bigger picture: I don't destroy trees, the convenience, the fact that this is probably a temporary transitional situation (and that this is part of the death throes of big obnoxious publishers). But it grinds me to do things that support bad MBA-think. And I'm often paying more than full price for something that I can't use the way I can use a print book: I can't loan a Kindle book to someone the way I can loan a physical book. I know that, as ebook readers become ubiquitous, I will eventually have the satisfaction of seeing the big publishers that are pulling these shenanigans go out of business -- who will need them when you can just publish an ebook directly? -- but in the meantime I feel abused. Especially because Amazon also provides their attractive used-book marketplace (and some of those have started providing Amazon Prime shipping), it takes an obvious choice (buy the ebook) and makes it a question again.

One other problem I came across was the blog-publishing service provided by Amazon. There are lots of blogs you can read -- for 99 cents a month. Since most of those blogs are free elsewhere, and it appears that if the blogger charges for the Kindle service the cost becomes more than 99 cents a month, apparently the 99 cents is a baseline fee that Amazon charges. I'm sure 12$ per year sounds very reasonable to Amazon, but if you read more than a few blogs this rapidly becomes an annoying amount of money. I'd be fine paying 12$/year to read all blogs of my choice; that would be a no-brainer. But 12$/year for each blog is also a no-brainer (the answer is "no"). I'll save that money for an iPad. Note that it is possible to use Kindle's browser to read blogs, although I'm sure what you get with the paid service is more elegant and useful.

Summary: The technology is terrific. The economic model needs work. And there are still a fair number of questions I haven't answered, such as: Are there sources of free books, and where are the best ones? Can I get these from the local library? (I know there are issues currently being worked out, with the publishers trying to impose arbitrary short-sighted restrictions that -- not surprisingly -- only benefit the publishers).

Until they figure it out and return the prices to reasonableness, I won't be buying many Kindle books. If publishers are going to punish me for buying a Kindle, then I am inclined to punish back, by using the alternatives that produce less profit for them -- the print version, or even better, a used book.

Coincidentally, O'Reilly Radar published a piece discussing ebook prices here.

Brice Busselman

Posts: 1
Nickname: bricebus
Registered: Mar, 2011

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Mar 26, 2011 7:24 PM
Reply to this message Reply
Hi Bruce,

Project Gutenberg ( is a good source of free ebooks.

You should have bookmark functionality. I have a 3rd-gen WiFi+3g Kindle (Version 3.1 according to the Settings screen), and it's web browser has a bookmark feature. While in the browser, I press the "Menu" button on the keyboard and a vertical menu pops up with several items, two of which are "Bookmarks" - which shows all existing bookmarks - and "Bookmark This Page".

Eddy Young

Posts: 2
Nickname: jeyoung
Registered: Jan, 2007

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Mar 27, 2011 1:48 AM
Reply to this message Reply
I don't have a Kindle device but use the Kindle app on my phone and on my netbook. Until now, I have found eBook prices to be lower than harcopy prices for some scifi and non-scifi, so I am hoping that the overpricing trend you mention is only in the US.

Daniel Sobral

Posts: 80
Nickname: dcsobral
Registered: Aug, 2008

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Mar 28, 2011 12:48 PM
Reply to this message Reply
The funny thing about this is that it was Apple that made this change possible for the publishers. It offered them a contract which let them decide what price a book would be sold for, with 30% royalties for the seller.

Amazon had a contract where the publisher would be paid a fixed price, but which led Amazon undercut its profit margin -- or even sell at loss. Which it, in fact, did with best sellers.

Given the alternative provided by Apple in the weeks leading to the iPad launch, Amazon was forced to offer a contract like Apple's.

Mike Capp

Posts: 11
Nickname: mikecapp
Registered: Aug, 2005

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Mar 30, 2011 10:57 AM
Reply to this message Reply
Pricing aside, does the ecosystem lockin not bother you? Tying long-lived data to a single client vendor seems like a huge step backwards. You might like the Kindle clients now; are you sure they'll still be the best in 20 years' time?

Re your blogs issue: I think Calibre can load feeds onto various readers, and I think it can talk to Kindles. I'm hoping that Readability will start to do something in this area; their "70% of subscription revenue goes to writers" business model is one of the better reimbursement schemes I've seen.

Sources of free books: I've found Gutenberg a bit hit-and-miss, with proofreading frequently absent once you stray off the beaten track of big-name classics. The project's focus on plaintext as the master format is also an issue, since it loses any typographical or layout improvements. I've mostly settled on - it's not perfect by any means, but the baseline is better.

Bruce Eckel

Posts: 875
Nickname: beckel
Registered: Jun, 2003

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Apr 1, 2011 12:46 PM
Reply to this message Reply
RE: Ecosystem lockin -- so far it seems like there are standard formats that work across ebook readers. But the primary motivation for buying the Kindle is to have a stable of ebook readers so that we can make sure we get good quality results on all of them. I think it will be an expanding marketplace, which will eventually reduce lockin.

Mike Capp

Posts: 11
Nickname: mikecapp
Registered: Aug, 2005

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Apr 4, 2011 12:33 PM
Reply to this message Reply
> RE: Ecosystem lockin -- so far it seems like there are
> standard formats that work across ebook readers.

Not really. Amazon is pushing AZW, which is essentially rebadged MOBI plus proprietary DRM. Nobody else can read that. Pretty much everyone else is pushing EPUB, usually with Adobe DRM. Kindle can't read that. In the absence of DRM you can interconvert EPUB and MOBI pretty easily, but since almost all commercial ebook sales are DRMed that doesn't help you much.

All in all, the current situation is a mess.


Posts: 1
Nickname: jmsnr
Registered: Apr, 2011

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Apr 5, 2011 9:31 AM
Reply to this message Reply
Its seems the publishers have learned nothing from the pain of the Music/Movies industry. The pricing strategy adopted or being adopted will simply lead to more and more eBook piracy and engaging in a battle that, like the drug and music wars just simply can not be won by dracion policies and DRM. And then everybody's a looser.

Charles Howard

Posts: 1
Nickname: sheeptick
Registered: Apr, 2013

Re: Kindle From Another Planet Posted: Apr 5, 2013 7:12 AM
Reply to this message Reply
Amazon charge UK customers 20% VAT for ebooks, but only pay 3% VAT by claiming to be based in (I think) Luxgembourg!

Flat View: This topic has 8 replies on 1 page
Topic: Interfaces vs Inheritance (or, watch out for Go!) Previous Topic   Next Topic Topic: We will not ship shit.

Sponsored Links


Copyright © 1996-2019 Artima, Inc. All Rights Reserved. - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use