The Artima Developer Community
Sponsored Link

Weblogs Forum
Excerpt: Beyond Lifestreams, the inevitable demise of the Desktop Metaphor

0 replies on 1 page.

Welcome Guest
  Sign In

Go back to the topic listing  Back to Topic List Click to reply to this topic  Reply to this Topic Click to search messages in this forum  Search Forum Click for a threaded view of the topic  Threaded View   
Previous Topic   Next Topic
Flat View: This topic has 0 replies on 1 page
Eric Freeman

Posts: 30
Nickname: erictfree
Registered: Apr, 2003

Excerpt: Beyond Lifestreams, the inevitable demise of the Desktop Metaphor (View in Weblogs)
Posted: Dec 13, 2004 10:21 PM
Reply to this message Reply
Summary
Search has become the holy grail of the desktop. While search on the desktop is nothing new - Microsoft has been pursuing WinFS in fits and starts over more than the last decade - this time something is different: everyone thinks it's important.
Advertisement
MIT Press is publishing a book this summer titled "Beyond the Desktop: Integrated Digital Work Environments," edited by Mary Czerwinski (Microsoft) & Victor Kaptelinin (Umea University), and I'm fortunate to have been asked to contribute a chapter on the Lifestreams work that Gelernter and I did in the mid '90s. Here's a small sample from that chapter:

Beyond Lifestreams: the inevitable demise of the Desktop Metaphor

Search has become the holy grail of the desktop. The predominant search companies are moving into desktop search as a way to extend their reach and operating systems makers are moving aggressively in this direction as well. Integrating search into our desktop environments is not a new development - Microsoft has been pursuing WinFS in fits and starts over more than the last decade - but this time something is different: everyone thinks it's important.

Why is there a growing interest in search on the desktop? Many attribute this interest to the "googlization of the desktop." The thinking goes: If my desktop is becoming as complex and hard to navigate as the Web, then why not apply the principles that work on the Web to my desktop? It's not a half-bad idea and its early success clearly demonstrates a need for new technologies (and possibly new metaphors) that can help us manage our electronic lives.

But is "desktop search" what we're really after? Will it allow us to finally manage the deluge of information pouring into our desktops? We didn't think so in the early '90s and we don't think so now. Our claim: To fully deal with the problem we need to break from the desktop metaphor and move to a model that removes the overhead and design constraints introduced by that metaphor. Search on the desktop is actually a step in the right direction, and by moving in that direction we've gained something quite valuable: an alternative model for how users might approach taking back control of their electronic lives. In fact, over the last decade, Web search has primed users for a different style of managing their electronic lives. However, as we'll see, we're not there yet; search is a necessary component of such a model; but it won't be sufficient by itself.

In 1994 David Gelernter and I undertook what some considered a radical approach to fixing our electronic lives by creating an alternative to the desktop metaphor. Our approach, Lifestreams [Free][Gel], is a software architecture for managing personal electronic information. The approach was radical in the sense that Lifestreams threw out filenames, folders and static filing and in their place provided a simple data structure: a time-ordered stream of documents combined with a small number of powerful operators for locating, organizing, summarizing and monitoring information. Our prototype implementation at Yale University realized many of the system's defining features and allowed us to experiment with the model's key ideas. Later commercial releases implemented a narrower set of Lifestreams' features, yet met real world usage.

Ten years later one only has to look as far as Apple's "iApps" (not to mention quite a few other efforts) to see many of Lifestreams features in action. While we make no claim that our work directly, or even indirectly, influenced Apple or a number of other software vendors, we have always claimed that the defining features of Lifestreams were natural and would end up in information management systems down the road. That now appears to be happening and as a result there is some renewed interest in our early work. So, in this Chapter we'll take a look back at the early work we did in alternative desktop metaphors.

-Eric

Topic: New Jini Wiki Previous Topic   Next Topic Topic: Heron just got Slashdotted


Sponsored Links



Google
  Web Artima.com   

Copyright © 1996-2014 Artima, Inc. All Rights Reserved. - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Advertise with Us