The Artima Developer Community
Sponsored Link

The Philosophy of Ruby
A Conversation with Yukihiro Matsumoto, Part I
by Bill Venners
September 29, 2003

<<  Page 2 of 4  >>


Orthogonal versus Harmonious

Bill Venners: Dave Thomas also claimed that if I ask you to add a feature that is orthogonal, you won't do it. What you want is something that's harmonious. What does that mean?

Yukihiro Matsumoto: I believe consistency and orthogonality are tools of design, not the primary goal in design.

Bill Venners: What does orthogonality mean in this context?

Yukihiro Matsumoto: An example of orthogonality is allowing any combination of small features or syntax. For example, C++ supports both default parameter values for functions and overloading of function names based on parameters. Both are good features to have in a language, but because they are orthogonal, you can apply both at the same time. The compiler knows how to apply both at the same time. If it's ambiguous, the compiler will flag an error. But if I look at the code, I need to apply the rule with my brain too. I need to guess how the compiler works. If I'm right, and I'm smart enough, it's no problem. But if I'm not smart enough, and I'm really not, it causes confusion. The result will be unexpected for an ordinary person. This is an example of how orthogonality is bad.

Bill Venners: In other words, the orthogonal features will work once the compiler writer understands them and gets them to work. But it is hard for programmers to understand it when they look at it, because it is complicated, because I have to figure out how these two things go together.

Yukihiro Matsumoto: The orthogonal features, when combined, can explode into complexity.

Bill Venners: So what's the alternative? What would be more harmonious?

Yukihiro Matsumoto: Just pick up one of those two to put into the language. You don't have to do everything that you can think of. You need to pick one of them, even though both are good.

<<  Page 2 of 4  >>

Sponsored Links

Copyright © 1996-2018 Artima, Inc. All Rights Reserved. - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use